Nothing beats the smell of baking bread or homemade cookies in the oven.
Behind every great baked good is a great mixer. If you’re in the market for a new stand mixer, it can be hard to pick the best device for your kitchen.
Two top brands you may have encountered are KitchenAid and Breville. Both sell great mixers, but which one is right for you?
To determine the winner of Breville vs KitchenAid, we’ll look at the flagship of each company: The KitchenAid KSM150PSCU Artisan and the Breville BEM800XL Scraper Mixer Pro. Let’s compare!
Breville vs KitchenAid: Price
Often, the first thing shoppers look at is the price point.
The KitchenAid Artisan is the more expensive of the two stand mixers, selling for $379.99.
The Breville Scraper Mixer Pro is a bit cheaper at $299.99.
The Breville vs. KitchenAid price difference is likely not just about the machinery, but about the brand name.
KitchenAid is an iconic American company that has been selling mixers since 1919. A household name, “KitchenAid” has become synonymous with stand mixers for many families.
Breville has only been making kitchen appliances since the late 1950s, after making radios and mine detectors during World War II. An Australian company, Breville has only been focused on selling overseas the last 15 years.
For many Americans, Breville is the young newcomer, while KitchenAid is the grizzled veteran with a reliable reputation. Let’s take a look at some other aspects to consider when researching Breville vs KitchenAid comparisons.
Size and Capacity
Both the Artisan and the Scraper Mixer Pro are mid-sized stand mixers, with 5-quart bowls. Both are appropriate for standard home use. Hardcore bakers may want to opt for a larger capacity mixer.
The two devices have some variation in their dimensions. The KitchenAid measures at 8.75″ L x 14.3″ W x 13.3″ H. The Breville is longer but not as wide, with measurements of 13 3/4″ L x 8 3/4″ W x 14 1/2″ H.
The Breville is the lighter of the two devices, weighing in at 21.4 pounds compared to the KitchenAid’s 26 pounds. Lighter devices are easier to move and carry if your mixer doesn’t have a permanent place on your counter. However, extra weight means more stability when the mixer is running at high speeds with heavy loads.
Speed and Power
The KitchenAid Artisan comes with 10 speed settings. The company recommends to only use Speed 2 when kneading yeast doughs.
The speed control for the KitchenAid is a horizontal switch that slides to the desired speed. The switch offers some resistance, so users may apply excessive force to slide it and push it to the wrong setting.
The Breville Scraper Mixer Pro has more options, with a 12-speed system.
The Breville’s speed control is a rotating circular dial. The dial provides click feedback to indicate an adjustment.
Power-wise, the Scraper Mixer Pro checks in with a higher wattage, at 550 W. The Artisan’s wattage is 325 W.
It’s important to note that wattage does not directly correlate to mixing power. It usually has a higher correlation to energy efficiency.
Performance-wise, Breville vs KitchenAid is a relatively even battle. So besides price, what are the key differences between the two? Here are difference makers for both devices.
KitchenAid Pro: Wide Variety of Add-Ons
The biggest benefit of the KitchenAid Artisan is that it doesn’t just function as a stand mixer.
The power hub of the Artisan doesn’t just provide a motor for the mixer. There’s a port on the nose of the head that allows users to connect various other KitchenAid attachments.
It can function as a food processor, a juicer, an ice cream maker, a grind mill and a cheese shredder. You can grind meat and squeeze said meat into sausage casings. You can press and roll homemade pasta and then cut it into the style of your choice, be it spaghetti or ravioli.
Unfortunately, these add-ons aren’t included with the mixer and are sold separately. But because you already have the motor, buying the attachments can be cheaper than buying a full specialty device.
Having one device with several attachments takes up less storage space in your kitchen than having several individual devices.
Plus, any questions or customer service-related situations all go through one company, making things a bit simpler for you.
If you want a multi-purpose unit for your kitchen, investing in the Artisan and its attachments may be a good idea.
Breville Pro: Timer
A convenient feature included on the Scraper Mixer Pro is a built-in timer.
The timer goes up to 10 minutes. When it expires, the machine automatically turns off.
The side of the mixer also includes an indicator of how much time may be appropriate depending on what you’re mixing. This is a helpful inclusion for inexperienced bakers and cooks.
If you’re in a busy kitchen, having such a timer can be very valuable. Overmixing can ruin a recipe. The timer allows you to do other work with peace of mind.
The KitchenAid does not include a timer or auto-shutoff. If these features are a game changer for you, the Breville has the advantage.
KitchenAid Con: No Overload Protection
The KitchenAid Artisan does not include overload protection. This means that there’s no internal sensor that triggers the device to shut off if the engine is getting overworked.
If the mixer is running too fast for too long, or the material being mixed is too difficult, it causes strain on the motor. Overload protection prevents motor burnout and helps protect your investment.
Overload protection comes standard on the Scraper Mixer Pro, but it’s not a feature of the Artisan.
Breville Con: Lack of Customization
Compared to the Artisan, the Scraper Mixer Pro isn’t very customizable.
The Breville doesn’t include the variety of specialty device attachments that the KitchenAid does. It’s a stand mixer, and nothing else.
In addition, the Breville only comes in three colors: Stainless steel, red, and black. In contrast, the KitchenAid is available in over 30 different colors.
If you’re looking for a versatile, personalized kitchen device, the Breville isn’t the top candidate.
The Final Verdict
Both devices would be great additions to any kitchen. To decide the winner of the Breville vs KitchenAid battle, it depends on your intended use of the devices.
If you’re looking for a regular stand mixer, the Breville Scraper Mixer Pro is the top choice. It’s cheaper while having similar performance. The Breville also includes several features that make mixing safer and more convenient.
However, the possibilities with the KitchenAid Artisan are nearly endless. If you want to fill out your kitchen with an all-around specialty device, investing in the Artisan and its attachments is a great option.
For more reviews, comparisons, and other information about stand mixers, check out Kitchen Tool Reviews’ stand mixers blog.